In the late autumn of 1988, an unheated fifteen-passenger touring van rumbled across the snow-covered highways of southern Illinois. Inside sat a handful of exhausted young actors hired by Chicago’s legendary **The Second City** touring company. Among them were a 26-year-old Chicago street veteran named **Paul Dinello**, an eccentric North Carolina transplant named **Amy Sedaris**, and a serious, bookish Northwestern University graduate named **Stephen Colbert**.

By all accounts, they should have hated each other. Instead, that icy touring bus became the incubator for a thirty-five-year artistic partnership that would reshape American satire.

The Initial Clash: “The Cabbie” vs. “The Pretentious Actor”

When Colbert first met Dinello, the friction was immediate:

  • Stephen Colbert had studied serious dramatic theater at Northwestern University. He wore tweed jackets, read philosophy, and initially regarded improvisational comedy as a lesser artistic pursuit.
  • Paul Dinello, an Italian-American kid from Chicago’s rough-and-tumble South Side, had driven a taxi cab to pay his bills, possessed razor-sharp street smarts, and had little patience for academic pretension.

Colbert later admitted: “I thought Paul was a hoodlum. He wore a leather jacket, smoked cigarettes, and looked like he was about to steal my watch.”

Dinello was equally unimpressed: “I thought Stephen was the most pretentious college boy I’d ever met in my life. He spoke with perfect diction and acted like he was waiting for the curtain to rise at Stratford-upon-Avon.”

Amy Sedaris: The Universal Catalyst

The woman who bridged the divide was Amy Sedaris. Sedaris was unlike anyone Colbert or Dinello had ever encountered. Hailing from Raleigh, North Carolina, Sedaris was tiny, fearless, and utterly unhinged on stage. She would smear greasepaint across her face, talk in bizarre high-pitched voices, and make bold physical comedic choices that left audiences stunned.

Sedaris instantly recognized that beneath Colbert’s polite exterior beat the heart of a brilliant mimic, and beneath Dinello’s tough-guy exterior was a deeply sensitive, hilarious writer. She forced them to sit together on the bus, sharing potato chips and playing improv word games until the icy tension thawed into mutual admiration.

The Second City Chemistry Formula

By 1990, the trio was performing together on the Second City Mainstage in Chicago. They developed an unmistakable collective voice: 1. Sedaris supplied the wild, surreal grotesque character work. 2. Colbert supplied the razor-sharp intellectual satire and vocal gravitas. 3. Dinello supplied the narrative grounding, structural discipline, and streetwise cynicism.

When they decided to leave Chicago in 1993 to pitch television shows in New York, they did so as an inseparable collective. Within two years, Comedy Central gave them their first greenlight: Exit 57.

Archival Documents